The 20 Most Popular Nutrisystem Snacks & Sweets

Let’s face it: We all love to snack. Nutrisystem’s wide variety of sweet and savory nibbles allows you to enjoy all of your favorite snacks while you lose weight and get healthy.

While all of the treats on the Nutrisystem snack menu are tasty and weight loss approved, there are a few choice munchies that stand out from the crowd. Our customers have weighed in and deemed the following contenders the cream of the crop.

So whether you’re a current customer looking to add a little extra sweet or salty to your menu, or you’re just a fan of eating your favorite treats without any of the guilt, this Nutrisystem snack list is for you.

1. Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwich

With five grams of protein, four grams of fiber and only 130 calories, this chilly treat will quell any ice cream craving you have!

2. Dark Chocolaty Sea Salt Nut Square

Calling all nut lovers! This sweet and salty treat is the perfect snack to keep you feeling fuller for longer with its eight grams of fiber!

3. Orange Cream Bar

This classic dessert comes with all the sweetness of your favorite childhood ice cream bar. Creamy vanilla and orange ice creams are swirled together for a summertime treat that’s just 90 calories.

4. Mint Ice Cream Sandwich

The Mint Ice Cream Sandwich is a fan-favorite Nutrisystem snack that combines creamy mint ice cream with chocolaty wafers for the ultimate guilt-free indulgence. Perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth while staying on track with your weight loss goals, it’s a refreshing treat that’s truly “mint” to be!

5. Lemon Zest Cake

This light cake is perfect just out of the package. Pair it with berries as a SmartCarb or top it with low-fat whipped cream for an Extra! The good source of protein gives this cake an edge up over classic store-bought goodies.

6. Chocolate Brownie Sundae

Decadent fudge ripples and hunks of brownie make this a sundae you won’t want to miss. Since it’s made for weight loss, you can enjoy every last bite of it!

7. Fudge Bar

This fudge flavored pop is lip-licking good with it’s chocolaty taste and icy texture. This is the perfect treat to curtail any chocolate craving.

8. Chocolate Flavored Pretzels

Ever need something that’s both sweet AND salty? These milk chocolate pretzels are just what you are looking for. At only 140 calories, you can’t go wrong!

9. White Cheddar Popcorn

This light and tasty white cheddar cheese snack is perfect to pop open for those midday cravings or late night bites!

10. Chocolate Chip Cookies

Cookie monsters can go wild with these tasty chocolate chip cookies. Pour a glass of non-fat milk and dunk away!

11. Chocolaty Pretzel Bar

This sweet and savory bar is a show stopper with a whopping eight grams of protein! The caramel layer makes this sweet treat taste just like candy.

12. Toffee Crunch Cookies

Craving some crunch? Our mini Toffee Crunch Cookies are packed with fiber for a delicious treat you can feel good about snacking on.

13. Chewy Peanut Bar

Get the peanut butter and chocolate taste you crave in one delicious, guilt-free spin on the classic combo!

14. Chocolate Cupcake

The chocolate drizzle on top of this gooey and fluffy chocolate cupcake takes it to a whole new level of deliciousness. But with whole grains and no artificial flavors or sweeteners, you can still feel guilt-free indulging in it.

15. Chocolate Caramel Bar

Crispy, crunchy and gooey—all in one bar. With nine grams of protein, you’ll want to reach for this snack to power you through your day.

16. Butter Popcorn

Grab a bag of this buttery and salty popcorn the next time you pop in a good movie or just need a snack. This popcorn is a good source of fiber and flavor!

17. Lemon Cooler Cookie

Lemon Cooler Cookies are a healthier take on a nostalgic favorite, offering a burst of zesty lemon flavor with each bite. Not only do they taste great, but they’re also a good source of fiber, making them a top pick for satisfying your sweet tooth while staying on track.

18. Peanut Butter Cookie

If you go nuts for peanut butter, this is the cookie for you! It has all the chewy goodness without the diet-damaging side effects.

19. Strawberry Shortcake Cupcake

Indulge in the perfect blend of ripe strawberries and creamy whipped filling with our bakery-style strawberry shortcake cupcake. Packed with flavor and fiber, it’s the guilt-free treat you deserve!

20. Cheese Puffs

These light and puffy cheese snacks are a good source of fiber while also providing a much needed crunch for you savory snack seekers.

Explore the full Nutrisystem menu or stock up on these popular snacks right here!

Now that you’ve made your way through this delicious list of snacks and sweets, be sure to check out our customers’ favorite lunches! >