Your Top Personalized Grocery Picks

Article posted in:
grocery picks

You took the first step towards your new healthy lifestyle and have received your first personalized Nutrisystem order. Throughout your journey, you won’t just lose weight. You will learn about healthy choices, portion control and preparing nutritious meals that works best for YOU. When you reach your weight loss goals, you will feel confident in your ability to maintain your success and continue healthy living.

Along the way, you will add in grocery additions to your day and prepare your own Flex Meals and Snacks throughout the week. You will be shopping for PowerFuels, SmartCarbs, Vegetables, Extras and Free Foods for a balanced diet.

To go along with your personalized Nutrisystem program, you need personalized grocery picks that fit your needs. We know there are a lot of options, so we put together a list of YOUR top 10 grocery picks from each category to compliment your plan. Make sure to also print out your FULL personalized Grocery Guide for even more ideas by clicking here. This will provide more details on each category, proper portion sizes and more examples that will work for you.

Click here to view your full personalized Grocery Guide >

Tried Every Diet? 6 Reasons Nutrisystem is Different

Read More

Your Top 10 PowerFuels

grocery picks

With your personalized plan, PowerFuels should be near the top of your shopping list. PowerFuels are high-quality lean proteins that keep you fueled throughout your day. One PowerFuel is between 80 to 120 calories with at least five grams of protein.


If you’re a cheese lover, stick to low fat and part-skim options to keep saturated fat to a minimum. Cheese can also be higher in salt, so consider choosing lower sodium varieties when they are available. Swiss tends to be lower in sodium than other cheeses. Enjoy shredded cheddar in salads, a slice of Swiss in a low carb wrap or a piece of string cheese as a snack.


Eggs are another great PowerFuel option for you. One large egg or about three to four egg whites is considered one PowerFuel serving. You could enjoy an egg white and veggie omelet for breakfast or a hard-boiled egg at snack time. Check out these egg-cellent recipes >

Fish & Shellfish

Seafood such as fish and shellfish are delicious, lean choices. When measuring your seafood, keep in mind that a serving of white fish or shellfish is three ounces, while a serving of fatty fish is only two ounces. Avoid fish and seafood that is covered in breading and consider buying frozen for a cheaper alternative. Make some tuna salad or enjoy tilapia over roasted veggies for a filling Flex Dinner.

Lean Meat & Poultry

Lean meat and poultry are some of the higher protein foods on this list. Try to choose lean cuts of meat and poultry to reduce your saturated fat intake. If you enjoy the deli counter, ask for low sodium options if they are available and avoid more processed meats like bologna and salami. The serving size for lean meat is generally two ounces, while the portion for chicken or turkey is three ounces.

Nuts & Nut Butters

Nuts and nut butters are super versatile and full of healthy fats to keep you full all day long. Enjoy some peanut butter on celery or sprinkle cashews on your salad. There are plenty of ways to enjoy this nutty ingredient. The serving size of nuts is two tablespoons for whole nuts and one tablespoon for nut butters. Choose your nut butter here >

Protein Shakes

Protein shakes are a quick and easy way to fit PowerFuels into your day. You can use any protein powder that you enjoy, however, you should check the calories and adjust the serving size as needed. Whey protein shakes like Nutrisystem Protein and Probiotic Shakes are packed with protein and keep you full all day. If you are unable to tolerate dairy, soy or pea protein shakes would also be acceptable. One serving is generally two tablespoons of protein powder but check the label to ensure it fits into the PowerFuel guidelines.  Find a tasty recipe here >


Low fat yogurt is delicious as part of a breakfast or a snack. Greek yogurt tends to be higher in protein than regular yogurt. Choose yogurt that is free of added sugars and add your own sweetness using stevia or monk fruit.

Soy Products

If you’re unable to enjoy dairy, soy products make a tasty and high protein alternative. Soy cheese, milk and yogurt can replace dairy versions and would be a great option for you. If you want to enjoy a meatless Monday meal, use tofu or tempeh as your PowerFuel. Edamame and soy nuts are also perfect protein snacks to take with you on the go.

Check out your full list of personalized PowerFuels here >

Protein up Your Plate: The 15 Most Logged PowerFuels in NuMi

Read More

Your Top 10 SmartCarbs

grocery picks

SmartCarbs are nutrient-rich carbohydrates that are lower on the Glycemic Index and packed with fiber to keep you full. They are an important piece of your personalized meal plan and are included in several of your meal occasions throughout the day. Your SmartCarbs should be between 80 to 120 calories with at least three grams of fiber.

Ancient Grains

If you’re bored of rice, ancient grains are the perfect swap for your plan. They’re filled with fiber and a variety of other beneficial nutrients. Grains such as amaranth, barley, quinoa and millet are versatile and delicious. Learn more about 6 super-grains you should be eating >


With your personalized plan, you can truly enjoy an apple a day to keep the doctor away. This healthy fruit is full of fiber and the perfect mix of sweet and sour. Enjoy a medium apple with peanut butter or make your own homemade apple sauce without added sugar. Check out our recipe here >


SmartCarbs that pack a protein punch like beans are your best bet. Canned beans are convenient and easy to prepare. However, they can be high in sodium. Luckily, low sodium canned goods are becoming more popular and readily available in the grocery store. Add beans to chili and salad as a high fiber addition. Hummus made from chickpeas is delicious with fresh chopped veggies. The serving size for beans is a half cup. Learn how to eat more beans >


For a “berry” good breakfast or snack, enjoy some berries. They are a lower sugar fruit that is perfect for your personalized plan. One cup of blueberries, strawberries, blackberries or raspberries is considered one SmartCarb serving. If you find your berries going bad before you can enjoy them, consider buying frozen berries. They are very convenient and typically cheaper than fresh berries. Blueberries can add sweetness, fiber and nutrients to your plain Greek yogurt.


You may think that bread is completely off limits when trying to lose weight. However, you can enjoy higher fiber options like rye or whole grain made with flax seeds. Try making a healthy grilled cheese or tuna salad sandwich as a diet-friendly Flex Lunch.

Brown & Wild Rice

Certain rice varieties are also acceptable SmartCarbs. Select wild or brown rice as these contain more fiber than regular white rice. Make your own healthy sushi using brown rice, veggies, salmon and low sodium soy sauce. A half cup of rice is one SmartCarb serving.

Butternut Squash

Enjoy a noodle dish made from veggies! Butternut squash makes an awesome low carb noodle when used with a spiralizer. It has a similar taste and texture to sweet potatoes but with less calories and carbohydrates.


Starchy vegetables such as potatoes are allowed in moderation on your plan. They contain fiber and other beneficial nutrients. About a half cup of potatoes is considered one SmartCarb serving. Enjoy a baked sweet potato with butter spray or make our Healthier Potato Salad. Get the recipe here >


Green peas may seem like a like a vegetable because of their color.  However, they are technically a part of the legume family, says Healthline. This makes them higher in carbohydrates and an ingredient that should be enjoyed in moderation. Peas are high in fiber and can definitely be incorporated into your program. Stick to a half cup serving as a side dish or mixed into your salads or stir fry.


Pineapple is one impressive fruit. One cup is considered one SmartCarb serving and provides more than 100 percent of your recommended daily vitamin C, says Healthline. This sweet and sour SmartCarb is delicious on its own. However, you can also enjoy it over cottage cheese or in your smoothies. You could also throw it in your blender with a little almond milk to make a 2-Ingredient Pineapple Sorbet.

Check out your full list of personalized SmartCarbs here >

The 17 Most Logged SmartCarbs in NuMi

Read More

Your Top 10 Extras

grocery picks

Extras! Extras! Read all about them! Add a little more flavor to your day with Extras. You are allotted three Extras per day. One Extra contains 10 to 35 calories per serving. In total, you have an extra 105 calories to play around with during the day for things like condiments, beverages and more.

Almond Milk

Almond milk is gaining popularity and many love to use it as a low calorie alternative to milk. We recommend choosing an unsweetened almond milk because it doesn’t contain added sugars. Use it to make smoothies, soups and more. About one cup is considered one Extra.


Avocado is a delicious fruit filled with healthy fats. However, they are quite high in calories and should be kept in moderation. About one tablespoon or an eighth of an avocado is considered on Extra.

Coffee Creamer

If you enjoy waking up to a cup of joe, you can add one tablespoon of a low fat coffee creamer to your cup. Pick an option that doesn’t have added sugar to avoid unnecessary calories.


Condiments and spreads, such as ketchup, mayonnaise and relish can be enjoyed with care. However, stay conscious of your calorie intake by choosing reduced sugar and low fat options.

Maple Syrup

Add some sweetness to your meal plan with a pure maple syrup. It’s a less refined sweetener than sugar and provides a delicious flavor. However, keep in mind that it still contains sugar in higher amounts and is best enjoyed in moderation. It’s also important to purchase pure varieties that don’t contain added sugars or unhealthy ingredients. Drizzle a teaspoon over your Nutrisystem pancakes.

Salad Dressing

You may want to drizzle some salad dressing on your favorite bowl of non-starchy vegetables. Most flavors and varieties are acceptable. However, the serving size will vary based on the type you choose. For regular full fat dressings, about one teaspoon is one serving. If you’re going for a light or reduced fat dressing, you can have about one tablespoon since they are lower in calories. Make sure to check the label to ensure it is low in added sugars. Making your own salad dressing is also super simple and you can control the ingredients and flavors you add. Check out our salad dressing guide here >


Whoever said good things come in small packages was probably talking about seeds. Seeds are nutritional powerhouses and a must-have for your personalized plan. Make a chia seed pudding with unsweetened almond milk and cinnamon or top your salads with roasted pumpkin seeds. One serving of seeds is about one teaspoon.


Healthy oils, such as avocado oil, olive oil and flaxseed oil are essential for your healthy weight loss program. There are many different options, each with their own cooking uses, nutrient profile and health benefits. Have fun and try a variety of oils in order to find your favorites. Use them for cooking, baking and making your own homemade salad dressings.


Take your diet to the tropics with coconut. Although it’s technically a fruit, coconut is higher in calories and will fall into the Extra category. A tablespoon of dried, unsweetened coconut flakes is a sweet and crunchy addition to your trail mix and smoothie bowls. A half cup of coconut water is a refreshing beverage that’s delicious blended with pineapple or mango.


If you enjoy snacking, popcorn will be your favorite Extra. Plain, air-popped popcorn is quite low in calories. So low, in fact, that one whole cup is considered one Limited Extra on the plan. Make a fresh bowl for your movie night or try one of these easy recipes >

Check out your full list of personalized Extras here >

The Great Debate: Is It an Extra or a Free Food?

Read More

Your Top 10 Free Foods

grocery picks

Free Foods will be your best friend while on the Nutrisystem plan. These are condiments and other ingredients that are so low in calories, you can enjoy as much as you want. Free foods are anything less than 10 calories per serving. They are unlimited on the plan and can be a great addition to meals, snacks and veggies to add some flavor.

Butter Spray

Cook your vegetables in a low calorie butter spray to add a buttery tasty with almost no calories.

Citrus Juice

Citrus juice such as lemon and lime juice can add some zest to seafood, vegetables and even your water!

Fresh Salsa & Capers

Fresh salsa or capers are perfect toppers for a healthy salad. Both can add flavor and fiber to any dish, with very little calories.

Low-Sodium Soy Sauce & Hot Sauce

When you’ve run out of your limited Extras, low sodium soy sauce and hot sauce are low calorie flavor in a bottle! Keep them handy throughout your journey when you’re needing something spicy or savory.

Fresh Herbs, Spices & Seasoning Blends

With your personalized plan, there should be no shortage on flavor. Spice up your life and feel free to use your favorite fresh herbs, spices and seasoning blends. Spices and herbs don’t just bring flavor; many also come with amazing health benefits. We recommend selecting spices and seasoning blends that are low in sodium. Spice up your veggies, Flex Meals and Nutrisystem entrees to your liking!

Zero-Calorie Sweeteners

Even if you’re trying to lose weight, you can still enjoy some sweetness. Our favorite zero-calorie sweeteners include stevia, monk fruit and sugar alcohols like erythritol. Add a little to your tea, coffee or plain low fat yogurt.


Vinegar packs a punch of flavor with very little calories. Make a salad dressing with apple cider vinegar, flaxseed oil, garlic powder and Italian seasoning. You can even infuse your own vinegar with fresh herbs easily to add even more flavor.

Check out your full list of personalized Free Foods here >

12 Reasons Downloading the NuMi App Will Help You Lose Weight

Read More